ST. CROIX — A peaceful afternoon along the shores of St. Croix turned into a scene of heartbreak and heroism Thursday when a woman tragically lost her life following a shark attack at Dorsch Beach in Frederiksted. The victim has been identified as Arlene Lillis, 56, of Detroit Lakes, Minnesota, a beloved wife whose life was cut short during what should have been a serene moment by the sea.
According to authorities, the St. Croix 911 Emergency Communications Center received multiple frantic calls at approximately 4:28 p.m., reporting that a female swimmer had been bitten by a shark near the buoyed area at Dorsch Beach. Marine units, along with Fire and Emergency Medical Services personnel, were immediately dispatched as beachgoers rushed to help in the critical moments following the attack.
Fire officials later confirmed the severity of the injuries, stating that the woman’s arm had been completely severed during the incident. She was transported for emergency medical treatment but, despite the tireless efforts of first responders and hospital staff, Arlene succumbed to her injuries at the Juan F. Luis Hospital. The confirmation was made by V.I. Director of Communications Glen Dratte, who was present at the scene and later spoke with The Virgin Islands Consortium.
Among those who rushed forward to help was Christopher Carroll, a nurse who was staying nearby at Sand Castles on the Beach. Carroll described hearing screams from his hotel room and immediately sensing that someone was in desperate need of assistance. Without hesitation, he ran toward the shoreline, where he saw people pointing frantically toward the water.
Carroll, who previously worked as a lifeguard, entered the water and swam toward the woman. As he reached her, he was confronted with a devastating sight—blood surrounding her in the water, confirming she had been attacked by a shark. He took hold of Arlene and began the arduous task of towing her back toward shore.
As they moved closer to land, Carroll said the full extent of her injuries became heartbreakingly clear. Her left arm was gone from the elbow down, with only the upper bone and shoulder remaining. She appeared extremely pale, her lips turning blue. Yet even in those moments, Arlene remained conscious. Carroll recalled that she told him her name was Arlene, and he spoke words of reassurance to her, urging her to stay with him as he continued swimming.
Once they reached the beach, bystanders rushed in to help, carefully lifting Arlene from the water. Her legs were elevated, and attempts were made to stabilize her condition while awaiting emergency crews. Paramedics and EMTs arrived swiftly, placed her on a backboard, and transported her by ambulance to the hospital.
Despite the courage, compassion, and rapid response shown by both civilians and emergency personnel, Arlene did not survive. She was formally identified by her husband, Richard Lillis, who now mourns the sudden and unimaginable loss of his wife.
The tragedy has deeply affected the St. Croix community and beyond. Senator Kenneth Gittens released a statement expressing his condolences and reflecting on the broader implications of the incident.
“It is sad and shocking to hear of the apparent shark attack involving a female swimmer near the buoy at Dorsch Beach in Frederiksted. My heart goes out to her and her family, and I thank the courageous citizen(s) who assisted her to shore and the emergency first responders for their swift action. This incident underscores the urgent need to strengthen our hospitals and make rebuilding them a top priority this year.”
Arlene Lillis is remembered not only for the tragic circumstances of her passing but for the humanity shown in her final moments—surrounded by strangers who became heroes, united by their determination to save her life. Her death serves as a somber reminder of the unpredictable power of nature and the fragility of life, even in places of beauty and tranquility.
As her family, friends, and loved ones grieve, the community holds them close in thought and prayer. May Arlene Lillis rest in peace, and may her memory live on as a testament to courage, compassion, and the enduring impact one life can have on so many.